Every once and a while I stop and think about what it would be like if Al Gore was our president. I started thinking about it over the weekend when I heard reports of what Bush was saying about global warming while visiting countries in Europe. On Thursday, he reiterated his March 2001 view that the Kyoto Protocol would have crippled the U.S. economy when he said, “Kyoto would have wrecked our economy. I couldn’t in good faith have signed Kyoto.”
He was making the same claims during his 2000 campaign. Here’s what Al Gore had to say back then:
We can have a next-stage prosperity where you don’t have to build your lives around a fuel source that is distant, uncertain and easily manipulated. We will demand and develop new technologies to free ourselves from gas-tank price-gouging, and we will sell those technologies to the world. We’ll build a new generation of fuel-efficient vehicles — and then make it easy for families to afford them.
And…
There can be a next stage of prosperity in which American creativity builds not just a better product, but also a better planet, a next stage of progress in which it is an every-day accomplishment for Americans to develop path-breaking technologies that create millions of high-wage jobs, clean up the environment and combat global warming at the same time… A next stage of prosperity and progress in which we encourage and support the Edisons of tomorrow, and empower them to build a better, cleaner and more prosperous world.
Then I read a column by Nicholas Kristof about how the city of Portland, Oregon has done many of the things that Gore campaigned for in 2000:
Newly released data show that Portland, America’s environmental laboratory, has achieved stunning reductions in carbon emissions. It has reduced emissions below the levels of 1990, the benchmark for the Kyoto accord, while booming economically.
What’s more, officials in Portland insist that the campaign to cut carbon emissions has entailed no significant economic price, and on the contrary has brought the city huge benefits: less tax money spent on energy, more convenient transportation, a greener city, and expertise in energy efficiency that is helping local businesses win contracts worldwide.
“People have looked at it the wrong way, as a drain,” said Mayor Tom Potter, who himself drives a Prius hybrid. “Actually it’s something that attracts people. … It’s economical; it makes sense in dollars.”
Oh… so this is the direction our country would have taken if Gore were president. It doesn’t sound like it’s crippled Portland’s economy. In fact, Portland’s economy is prospering while it becomes more energy efficient and cleaner. This model sounds like a much better one than Bush’s old-school model built on more drilling for oil, developing nuclear power plants, and allowing energy companies to draft the Energy Plan-all of which lead to more consumption, less efficiency, dirtier air and dirtier water.
And as an added bonus, if Gore was our president, we wouldn’t be spending hundreds of billions of dollars a year and thousands of lives fighting an unnecessary war in Iraq where there just happens to be a whole lot of oil.
Dream on.